I Put A Spell On You: The Return of the Sanderson Sisters

Sun October 28th, 2018 - Minimum Age: 18+

The Sanderson Sisters are back from the dead, and no one wants to miss their return! Jay Armstrong Johnson and Danny Marin are proud to share this cast of kooky characters BACK by popular demand after two years of SOLD OUT shows. Come Little Children and celebrate Halloween Salem Style! Expect a bigger, better, and bolder new show with a rockin’ band Musical Directed by Benjamin Rauhala and amazing guests! This is one HALLOWEEN event you won’t want to miss. Come dressed in costume and join in on the PARTY! You might even win the costume contest!


Premium VIP Table Seating: $60
GA Table Seating: $40
Standing Room: $20

Johnson’s cabaret show at Feinstein’s/54 Below [was] sprawling musical potpourri... an engaging evening. He has the gift.
— Stephen Holden, The New York Times


Jay Armstrong Johnson (Winifred)

Jay Armstrong Johnson (Winifred)

Amanda Williams Ware (Mary)

Amanda Williams Ware (Mary)

Allison Robinson (Sarah)

Allison Robinson (Sarah)


Major Attaway    (Aladdin)

Major Attaway


Krysta Rodriguez    (SMASH)

Krysta Rodriguez


Andy Mientus    (SMASH)

Andy Mientus


Mykal Kilgore    (Encore’s Songs For A New World)

Mykal Kilgore

(Encore’s Songs For A New World)

Ali Ewoldt    (Phantom of the Opera)

Ali Ewoldt

(Phantom of the Opera)

Ahmad Simmons    (Carousel)

Ahmad Simmons


Natalie Joy Johnson    (Kinky Boots)

Natalie Joy Johnson

(Kinky Boots)

Marissa Rosen    (R.R.R.E.D.)

Marissa Rosen


Shawna Hamic    (Orange Is The New Black)

Shawna Hamic

(Orange Is The New Black)

Nick Rashad Burroughs    (Kinky Boots)

Nick Rashad Burroughs

(Kinky Boots)

Zak Reynolds    (Band Leader)

Zak Reynolds

(Band Leader)

Natalie Hinds    (Dani)

Natalie Hinds


Cody Jenkins    (Thackery Binx)

Cody Jenkins

(Thackery Binx)

Kathryn Priest    (Allison/Dance Captain)

Kathryn Priest

(Allison/Dance Captain)

Jennifer Reed    (Back Up Vocalist)

Jennifer Reed

(Back Up Vocalist)

Maddox Martin    (Max)

Maddox Martin


Allison Griffith    (Back Up Vocalist)

Allison Griffith

(Back Up Vocalist)